Lastchance vs. Mayi ESL Decision

Posted by Nakara at 13:45 28/1/2005.

With all the controversy that has been going since Lastchance played Mayi in the ESL UK cup, Lastchance have now been handed a default win. The result originally was 16-12 to Mayi, but after protests from the Lastchance guys the result has been overturned. The reason for this turn in events is because a certain player (Hkitty) for Mayi "forgot" to record a demo in the second half, which is the half that Lastchance believes this player was suspect.

Lastchance will now go on to face Virgins in the quarter finals on Wednesday 2nd February the same day as their member announcement, exciting stuff.

Comments

M4ce
intensiveSports
13:58 28/1/2005
o.0

good cos countless times i've played and we say "demos" at the start, we're losing but no whine and we eventually lose, get to irc and its always "i forgot to record" or "here's my demo but its broken" (dated 3 or 4 weeks previously)

:/

n1 lc lads + ESL

[Edited by M4ce at 14:03 28/1/2005] [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
oldlady
14:00 28/1/2005
damn! [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Choke|MaT
Choke
14:01 28/1/2005
lol sh*t happens! [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
AdY
14:01 28/1/2005
:) [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Inferus
14:05 28/1/2005
Good job InspectorAdam :D

Nice to see a sensible decision. I would of liked to of seen the CSGN screenshots of this guy, just to see what his fps truely is ;/ [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
jayy
14:06 28/1/2005
lick lick lick [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Solid`
Choke
14:08 28/1/2005
So they didnt get done for cheating, just forgetting to record?
lc were unlucky last night defaultin, spose this is something good for them :) [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Xtreme^
14:09 28/1/2005
Good, I watched the HLTV of that hkitty and he was wallhacking imo. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
bigwest
14:11 28/1/2005
they did seem to soak it up a bit. We should have asked for demos in our match in first round versus them .I Bet some of them didnt record. But dunno if the admins would have overturned it for 'us'.. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Katori
Choke
14:11 28/1/2005
lol poor Virgins gotta go through it all over again, gl lads :) [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Ripper
Rush!
14:11 28/1/2005
god dammit american football sucks [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
bigwest
14:12 28/1/2005
Is this going to lead to everyone asking for demos in every match, just in case someone forgot to record a half. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Choke|MaT
Choke
14:13 28/1/2005
Shame the CSGN screenshots will only be available in CSGN competitions. Still not sure why the Punkbuster screenshot thingy was stopped from being used, or even that Octavian movie thing. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
$aVa$
ImaGine
14:14 28/1/2005
Unf***inglucky! ANTS.eu

Whether they like annoying me, are suicidal, or just plain stupid remains to be seen, but if I had to pick one of the above, I’d pick all of the above. They’re really annoying, these damn insects. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Nakara
14:14 28/1/2005
that american game with the sticks and thingy u have to run around is much better ripper [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
LiamC
14:16 28/1/2005
nothing to say

UPLOADING UR DEMOS NOW! LASTCHANCE! [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
g00z
quintessential
14:20 28/1/2005
hahaha what a bunch of whining c**ks lc are [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Choke|MaT
Choke
14:20 28/1/2005
I've never ever had a problem with broken personal demos and with all the movie producing I've done in the past I've recorded around 2500 personal demos of games. Also there's no reason to stop recording midway through a match.

Can't stand it when people use those blatently sh*t excuses! It always makes it look like they've got something to hide. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Inferus
14:24 28/1/2005
I've recorded around 2500 personal demos of games.

And I bet you still haven't found any good frags! ;D

Anyone got a link to ESL rules? i'm feeling lazy. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
DiesE|
14:26 28/1/2005
well, the 2nd avi that AdY made looked utter bollocks. whether its just a random burst cos the guy at the door has caleld i dunno but it looks suspect to moi.


That was good intelligence, very good intelligence. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
]-[ao
AnTs Clan
14:26 28/1/2005
this is from cup admin Mike
http://www.ukterrorist.com/columns/7036/
this is ESL rules:
http://www.esl-europe.net/uk/cs/5on5/mr15/cup/rules/ [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
enc|mike
14:29 28/1/2005
Choke|MaT: as in the ladders of whole of the ESL there must be 2 maps played. As everyone apart from the UK Scene knows what structure is, I know for a fact that 95% of ESL players record a demo for each half. The main reason being, if there is a cheat accusation the opponent has to upload whichever half the protest creator asks for. The creator can only ask for 6 demos in total and 2 from each player. For example.

Player1: Dust2 CT + Nuke T
Player4: Dust2 T + Nuke T
Player5: Nuke T + Nuke CT [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Pimpboy
feo
14:30 28/1/2005
thats what i like to see a 0 tolerance to the rules [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Rude^
Jay Bee Eye!
14:32 28/1/2005
ul ants [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Inferus
14:33 28/1/2005


6.2. Demos and replays
If your game supports a demo- or replay-function, it is obligatory for all players to use it. The demos are to be kept for at least 14 days and must be presented to the admin at request.

If a player or team suspects that another player or team is violating a regulation during a game, the demo can be demanded of the opposing team straight away. The admins are only to be called in, when suspicions continue to exist even after the demos have been viewed. In this case, the clan or player may proceed and send the admin the game demos. The admin will then take the appropriate action.

It is recommended to voluntarily make all demos available to the public in order to keep the ladders transparent and interesting. For specific rules, please read the respective game rules.
[ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
w1cked
Croydon
14:34 28/1/2005
Dont see why his POV demo was needed if HLTV was on the server?

ul AnTs [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Inferus
14:35 28/1/2005
HLTV doesn't give the same quality as POV. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
LiamC
14:35 28/1/2005
because they said HLTV DEMO has delay... wicked [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Hotshot
Choke
14:36 28/1/2005
lc-|Kardy [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
ColdAsIce
ImaGine
14:42 28/1/2005
:D [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
$aVa$
ImaGine
14:43 28/1/2005
Record a HLTV and a POV demo of the same match, and compare them and you will notice a big difference. There are lots of animations, sounds etc. missing and added lag/delay on the hltv one.

I wouldn't ban people because of hltv, unless it's rather blatant of course.

Plus the rules state pov demos. Did all of LC record? duh :x [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
stabby
Virgins!
14:43 28/1/2005
^^^ [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Pimpboy
feo
14:44 28/1/2005
this is s***e really they cheated their way to this victory and this makes it look like lastchance got the default on a gay technicality :( [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
ellven
14:45 28/1/2005
but it is [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Inferus
14:46 28/1/2005
Plus the rules state pov demos. Did all of LC record? duh :x

Did lc do anything dodgy? :) [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
ColdAsIce
ImaGine
14:47 28/1/2005
Pimpboy could you really see them getting banned when there is no concrete evidence of them hacking?

Its just good that they have found this loophole :) [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
$aVa$
ImaGine
14:47 28/1/2005
Let's ask MAGI or whatever. :P [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Choke|MaT
Choke
14:49 28/1/2005
Mike, if that's the case, I hope that there's admins to tell teams to record at the beginning of each half, otherwise that's a bit out of order. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
M4ce
intensiveSports
14:51 28/1/2005
wtf are MaYi? Ants.eu? who r these randoms? how many LANs they been to?

my bad if the answers r blatantly obvious i'm no lc fanboy :/ [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
AdY
14:51 28/1/2005
people saying we are just whining because we lost take a look at the synergy game in CSGN, it was 19-11 i think but nothing dodgy happened, AnTs are the strangest team ever and a far from legit ! :) [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
bigwest
14:53 28/1/2005
the live message the admin spammed at beginning of each half did remind them to start recording. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Pimpboy
feo
14:54 28/1/2005
yes lastchance did one dodgey thing UNDONES WALLSHOT in B WAS UTTER BULLs*** !!! IT WAS LOCK ON!!!! ;P [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
RazeH
14:54 28/1/2005
yer 19-11 gg ady <3 to me [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
ellven
14:55 28/1/2005
ady u got what u want so stop abetting [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Inferus
14:55 28/1/2005
Lastchance team had only just been reformed when you played synergy hadn't it AdY?

You can normally just 'feel' something being wrong when you play against someone. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Pimpboy
feo
14:56 28/1/2005
it would be truly hilarious if someone from lc did forget to record :D [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Katori
Choke
14:57 28/1/2005
"I've recorded around 2500 personal demos of games.

And I bet you still haven't found any good frags! ;D"

Now that made me laugh hehe see the truth can be funny too! ;) [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Flavas
Game Dimension Online
14:58 28/1/2005
Inferus
14:46 28/1/2005 Plus the rules state pov demos. Did all of LC record? duh :x

Did lc do anything dodgy? :)


so your telling me unless your dodgy you can break the rules? :) [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Pimpboy
feo
14:59 28/1/2005
i think they merced in the lastchance game as well my alsation went missing on that night its currently under investigation :P [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
MonkH
15:00 28/1/2005
GMO played them at UKT finals in the qualifers it came down to last round 1on1 or summit very close and GMO finished 4th or 5th or summit [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
M4ce
intensiveSports
15:00 28/1/2005
so your telling me unless your dodgy you can break the rules? :)

na 'natu' got owned by clanbase, any cheats from any clan should be dealt with all the same [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
AdY
15:01 28/1/2005
this is AnTs.eu not AnTs.uk [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
proxideZ
15:04 28/1/2005
imo Lastchance you got beat fair and square, and u whined. just face it u arent gunna win them all. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Inferus
15:05 28/1/2005
Well no flavas i'm not saying that, however even if one of lc was cheating then what i meant was, they must be hiding it so well it would be near impossible to prove.

Hard to explain what I mean :( [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
DiesE|
15:06 28/1/2005
so anyway, had she been fully awake i probably would have done more. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
ColdAsIce
ImaGine
15:17 28/1/2005
^ROFL [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
raaazzzzz
15:21 28/1/2005
"forgot" [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Flavas
Game Dimension Online
15:21 28/1/2005
yes i know what your saying about being dodgy and not recording is bad, just the recording rule is for EVERYONE if the rules state it, dodgy or not! :)

anyway were moving off the topic, if one of there players didnt record dodgy or not they should lose the game, and esp if hes dodgy so nice choice there by the admins [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
ins
15:22 28/1/2005
:( [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
ndm
15:28 28/1/2005
proxideZ = proxide? If so, please stop defending other cheats you hacking f***. If not, nevermind! [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
MonkH
15:31 28/1/2005

AdY
15:01 28/1/2005 this is AnTs.eu not AnTs.uk

AHHH ants.eu ..... is there a diffrence? :S i thought ants eu was uk aswell [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Champion
In The Zone
15:34 28/1/2005
ants.eu players play for ants.uk and ants.uk players play for ants.eu ... go figure [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Danneth
15:41 28/1/2005
ul AnTs [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
MadSpunk
Last Chance
15:41 28/1/2005
We still all have our demos yes, of both halves. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Tru
15:42 28/1/2005
so ants.eu is ants.uk then champion [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
$aVa$
ImaGine
15:50 28/1/2005
makes sense especially when they are all chinese basicly!? -_- [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
badER
16:11 28/1/2005
LOL what f***ing bulls***. AnTs were the better team, yet because one of there players forgot to record makes them lose the game? even thou there is HLTV recording. GG LC f***ing losers [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
ryano
theb0g
16:15 28/1/2005
I was thinking about turning on somebody who is a regular poster on ukt comments page and just constantly hurling unwarranted abuse at them. Any suggestions [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
DoZ
Anti-saviour of UKT
16:17 28/1/2005
Do me, do me! [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
v3zv3zv3zv3z
16:27 28/1/2005
Well watched the demo and couldnt find anything dodgy, ok some shots are pure luck, but overall mayi showed good tp on t side and worked b middle rushes really well, i remember kitty getting a 15-10 score thats really dodgy. Heard of other respected uk players who played against them there was nothing dodgy so find this all a bit weird discussion. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
StriKeN
unicon.cs
16:41 28/1/2005
only for last chance, I doubt admins would have given a flying f*** for any other mediocre team.

happens in all leagues, good teams get licked. But I suppose fair's fair, league won't get recognition and respect unless they have recognised and respected clans. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Choke|MaT
Choke
16:50 28/1/2005
funny you should say that Katori.... I still haven't looked thru any of them :P [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
brenje
reSonance
16:58 28/1/2005
No offence vezling mate, but i'd hardly call nixoh a 'respected player'.

Also the guys score has very little to do with it. Nobody in their right mind would cheat in a respected league against a respected team and go for a score of 45-0 because they would just draw attention to themselves. IF the guy was cheating then he achieved what he set out to do, which was beating lastchance, Regardless of his own scoreline.

Personally i think that those avi's are VERY dodgy, however not enough to make me 100% sure that the guy is infact cheating. I also think that somebody 'forgetting' to record a demo isnt enough to overide the original result and like striken said, i doubt this would have happened for a 'lower profile' team. GL in the quarter final though. ;D [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
alicat!
16:59 28/1/2005
Watched the demo nothing concrete at all, ants were clearly the better team. Unfortuanetly Lastchance are still living on past glory, their current team is nowehere near as good as it used to be. Unfortuanetly Strikens summed it up best, thats the way it goes. v.ul ants. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
[al]Honour!
17:03 28/1/2005
Everyone should record demo's, if you dont, its presumable that your hiding something. Your game might not be as smooth but if everyones effected then its fair (hardware variables will always exist but most people have computers that can run satisfactory anyway). [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
brenje
reSonance
17:03 28/1/2005
No offence to nixoh like ^^

And by the part about the demo, i meant if the guy from AnT's did just innocently forget (which i doubt he did.. but still) to record, its kinda harsh to overide the result. Especially when you consider that there was HLTV. However, if its in the rules.. its in the rules, still cant help thinking its a harsh rule. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
proxideZ
17:08 28/1/2005
exactly StrikeN & alicat! [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Flavas
Game Dimension Online
17:10 28/1/2005
rules are there for a reason and if you break them you should be punished, no matter how 'harsh' the rule is. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
aaNdy
got:Game
17:17 28/1/2005
nath knows :D [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Exocet
RemOte.uK
17:18 28/1/2005
if the dude remembered to stop his demo he should have remembered to start a new one up again. he didn't leave the server or anything. mayi even asked at the start of the game if they needed to record (HKitty asked i think?) so there is no excuse not to. the admin even spammed 'remember to record' a few times at the start of each half. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Add comment

Menu

News
Features
Events
Site
Search UKT:

User



Register here

Shoutbox

Nukz
[Link] rofl @ ady
00:58 3/7/2008

HooV
Burger
11:29 1/7/2008

Ashwee
i played some AoC its fairly great
17:11 27/6/2008

Coopsy
sob sob the good ol days of UKT :(
17:39 25/6/2008

BlondEh
anyone tried Age of Conan?
13:35 19/6/2008

[ expand ]