Gamespy: Top 10 reasons pro-gaming sucks

Posted by alpha at 16:06 7/4/2003.

Gamespy have posted a four-page article listing the top 10 reasons pro-gaming sucks. There are a couple of games-are-geeks stereotypes in there but there are also quite a few valid points. Here's a quick quote:

I don't liken professional gaming to playing Russian Roulette or filling your pants with gasoline while chain smoking Cuban cigars or anything like that. The idea is not completely without merit, but it is still significantly flawed.

[...]

Pro gaming will probably never get significantly bigger or more popular than it is now. Maybe it's already peaked.

Have a read of the full article and flame away.

Comments

Ho3x
16:09 7/4/2003
errr lol wp to that article! [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
VespR
16:10 7/4/2003
I actually agreed with virtually every point he made. I like games, I love competing with games, but he is right. As long as the games keep changing, there is no governing body and the rules are as he puts, "all over the place" it probably won't get any bigger than it is now.

Plz don't hurt me C|=P [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Obz
16:14 7/4/2003
FACT. whoever wrote that article lost a CS match last night. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
duck.
Online Multiplayer Gaming
16:16 7/4/2003
LOL [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
tpr`
16:17 7/4/2003
"Pro-gamers have no personality" - way to stereotype [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Ho3x
16:20 7/4/2003
yeah , tbh that guy cant acsept the fact hes a noob and has to cus down "pro-gamers" or something? [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Gryff
16:23 7/4/2003
the articles full of s***.

Darts is a sport.

The Counsel for the defense rests. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
duck.
Online Multiplayer Gaming
16:23 7/4/2003
LOL [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Smittins
16:24 7/4/2003
if I had to come up with a list of reasons that the author is an idiot I'd have a lot more than 10 [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Dev
theb0g
16:31 7/4/2003
lol [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Gryff
16:33 7/4/2003
ok heres a point by point blowaway.

10. omg CS isnt like hockey/football i cant win by beating people up k thx /me points to darts.

9. odd how quite a lot of people watched CPL finals on HLTV then.

8. CS has been around for several years, and they wont change it apart from tweaking the engine with new versions like CS. CS will never die :-]

7. Online Leagues dont work?

f*** me.
/me looks at CAL, Eurocup, and even P2P leagues like BWCSL and Jolt.

6. Pro-Gamers have no personality? Really? How many has this 'tard interviewed or lived with for a few weeks to find this out. Just stereotyping geeks further.

5. No mainstream appeal. Sorry so lets shut down all the non-mainstream music genres and lock people up for trainspotting.

4. Rules arn't consistent? How many sports were split on rules during their formation. Rugby league and rugby union anyone?
Football and American football?

3. Too many leagues?
How many people follow sub-conference level football? how many people play in sunday club leagues.
Once again theres probably more football leagues than online leagues and more people playing CS at anyone time. To conclude football sucks and will die shortly. Its peaked. Or possibly he's talking BOLLOCKX.

2. Pro-Gamers are too serious. huh? /me thinks back to some of the insane stuff seen at lans.
They call people n00bs?
Has this person been reading UKT comments to make this conclusion? or has he just played 30 minutes on your average CS public server.

and most importantly apparently...

Its meant to be fun.

It is fun. Does anyone who spends hours practicing their proffession such as a golfer etc not find it fun? Each to their own? Live and let Live?

To conclude.
Your wasting my precious air. Please drown in a puddle of mucus. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
iron
16:33 7/4/2003
Id have to agree with pretty much everything he says, bar the personality bit. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Anisty
16:50 7/4/2003
i would have to say that gryff's article is much better. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
acron^
Sector7G
17:11 7/4/2003
You tell em Gryff! [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
phonics
17:12 7/4/2003
in general the guy is right but his article is s***, bitter and miss-informed. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
OverlordRob
Asylum.uk
17:14 7/4/2003
Not a spectator sport? Only cos until now it hasnt had the support to. HLTV CPL Winter final had 13000 spectators....thats the same as a division 1 football match

In a few years time theyll be laods more support for spectating - people love it

I jsut think he wanted to be flamed for being controversial [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
phonics
17:15 7/4/2003
overlord a realistic comparison would be the billions of peopel who tune in for the world cup. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
maraschino
17:16 7/4/2003
who actually uses gayspy anyway
all the peeps on aol?

:P [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Obz
17:16 7/4/2003
a kinda agree CS is a bit dull to watch... but q3 team / 1v1 is excellent.

I doubt CS will be that game that lifts pro gaming.. but something will.. and it will be huge. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
R4nCiD
17:19 7/4/2003
If only what gryff said was true.

ul. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Mew
ClanNEW
17:21 7/4/2003
true'est words iv ever read. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
shads
theb0g
17:27 7/4/2003
i bet the guy who wrote it has fun in the uk2 league anyway [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Ara
17:37 7/4/2003
GRyff for president [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Ara
17:37 7/4/2003
ohh and btw, if it wouldnt be fun, ppl would quit? [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
OverlordRob
Asylum.uk
17:50 7/4/2003
phnoics u deserve a medal u said overlord and not overload like evryone else :)

i know its not same size as world cup but then again football is most watched sport in the world...my point was gaming spectating is just taking off and its not true no1 watches it [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
St00piD
Intrigue
17:53 7/4/2003
it was about 10000 or something watched CPL winter final, [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Az
RemOte.uK
18:02 7/4/2003
spot on....... [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
ND
18:02 7/4/2003
was 30k [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Scam
18:14 7/4/2003
The guy makes some good points, but his arguments for them are pitiful;

''Why watch other people play a game when you can just do the exact same thing yourself? ''

'Cos that doesnt apply to... hmn... EVERY SINGLE SPORT... [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
sU
Warped Reality
18:17 7/4/2003
well when u compare it to chess what 'sport' would you rather watch? As for the fun point of view, whats going to give u a bigger buzz, taking your opponents queen, or taking out 3 players on you tod in a semi final? [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Krispy
18:22 7/4/2003
gryff is win o/ [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
FuSe
18:31 7/4/2003
I think he's largely right about pro-gaming being in pointless in his "opinion". However he might think differently if he was a top CS or Quake player winning tournaments and generally having a laugh. i think he's right about appeal - cs will never appeal to as many people as football for example - i don't think, for various reasons.

People who enjoy chess might say that taking three players out would be less enjoyable? As for the online leagues example. I think they work but as he points out - they will never be as "fair" as say a football league. Look at the controversy over certain clanbase nations matches etc. "Serious" Gaming will always be a niche market, more people take football seriously than any other sport or game because it is easy to learn, fun to play and can be played virtually anywhere. Games are released constantly and are constantly being bettered - they may retain some of their community, but overall less people play. "I think he's right about pro-gaming being in pointless in his "opinion". However he might think differently if he was a top CS or Quake player winning tournaments and generally having a laugh. However i think he's right about appeal - cs will never appeal to as many people as say football i don't think, for various reasons. With CS being the exception. Far less people see the point in taking gaming seriously purely because it requires a computer, often to be anti-social and it is virtual. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
FuSe
18:36 7/4/2003
lol nice messed up comment [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
DK
Stalk Confront Engage Eliminate
18:54 7/4/2003
Sorry have to agree with alot of his points.

30k watched the CPL finals??

Ofcourse we are talking world wide here, as the teams were from all over the world. 30k turn out to watch an average footy team.

get over it, its a niche activity, participated by a small community in general and thats y u'll never have the 'pro-gaming' that u so desperately want/need. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
St00piD
Intrigue
18:58 7/4/2003
that X-Fire that used to be on TV was good [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
StriKeN
unicon.cs
18:59 7/4/2003
his number 1 point about playing NOT being fun is stupid

the fun is in the competition!!!! [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
shads
theb0g
19:17 7/4/2003
get over it, its a niche activity, participated by a small community in general and thats y u'll never have the 'pro-gaming' that u so desperately want/need.

everyone else has got over it, no one ever expected it to be the next "football" or anywhere near, its just llamas like this guy and u who are still caught up in the "l33ts" argument which died out 2 years ago when everyone else grew up that fail to see and try to spark up old flames that no one cares about anymore :x [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
gaz
eNvy!
20:24 7/4/2003
go gryff go [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
fez
09:08 8/4/2003
"The number of simultaneous connections on the NetFire HLTV servers peaked at 29,877, a world record according to Valve Software."

just to clear that one up ;) [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
St James
09:23 8/4/2003
That article was really funny, mainly criticising the fact that pro gaming does not have a wide appeal (hey, how long has it been going, 2-5 years?) and that it's not really a sport (talk about chess) or rules changing (give it some maturity, besides formula one sees a lot of changes every year).

Anyway, i think that article was written for fun (see the images ;) and the last point made, if not totally silly, proves it : pro-gaming is no fun, of course not, it's pro too!... [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
DK
Stalk Confront Engage Eliminate
12:06 8/4/2003
So Keith, how come we have posts here that simply reply to him being s*** at the game or a noob and that's his whole reason for posting his opinions.

It's typical of UK CS scene to reply to anybodies opinion by saying they are s*** and a noob thats why they say what they say. So the 1337 pricks are still out there. Read peoples comments before you post about the leetist attitude being gone. Alot of your post have been pro 'pro-gaming', so don't be a hypocite aswell as a tit.

As for you calling me a llama, s*** b***h I'd have thought you'd know better. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
shads
theb0g
12:53 8/4/2003
lol jay u ever heard of something called a joke, or arent people allowed to say them in hubcapstealingland coz all the trolls get insulted :x

and yes i have made some "pro pro-gaming" posts before but like i said no one actually cares anymore they just play the game for what it is [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
DK
Stalk Confront Engage Eliminate
12:59 8/4/2003
Keith, your comment had no hint of sarcasim or wit in it, unlike your hubcapstealingland reply which clearly implies your jestful intent.

Your other post was a seriously written point, however flawed. [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
shads
theb0g
16:02 8/4/2003
so i guess the :x on the end was a kiss of death [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
disty
00:43 9/4/2003
ok i may be wanderign away from the point of this all but who else feels Pac-Man World Champion Billy Mitchell is the son of satan?

dont believe me?

take another look at that pic.....

chilling :E [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
disty
00:45 9/4/2003
his eyes glow ffs [ Comment: Report | IP: Logged ]
Add comment

Menu

News
Features
Events
Site
Search UKT:

User



Register here

Shoutbox

Nukz
[Link] rofl @ ady
00:58 3/7/2008

HooV
Burger
11:29 1/7/2008

Ashwee
i played some AoC its fairly great
17:11 27/6/2008

Coopsy
sob sob the good ol days of UKT :(
17:39 25/6/2008

BlondEh
anyone tried Age of Conan?
13:35 19/6/2008

[ expand ]